Online ordering powered by Seamless
1667 1st Avenue, ()(212) 828-0888
Minimum order of $12.00 is required for delivery
Delivery estimate is 25-40 min (more info)
Unfortunately, Gotham Pizza (1st Ave) is not open at the delivery/pickup time that you selected. Please make sure that you've entered an address and try changing the time in the Order Information section to the right.
Seamless allows you to enjoy convenient online ordering from the best local restaurants. If you're ordering for the first time, start your order by entering your address to the right. Return users log in here.
Minimum order of $12.00 is required for delivery
Delivery estimate is 30 - 45 min (more info)
Print this menu
Dressing served on the side.
Real Parmigiano Reggiano cheese on every slice!
Gotham Pizza is well known on the Upper East Side for offering delicious pizza. Gotham Pizza is open for lunch and dinner so no matter what time you’re craving a delicious meal they can satisfy your hunger. Pizza pies and salads are prepared quickly and delivered to you right away. Gotham Pizza uses only the freshest ingredients around, ensuring that every dish is of the highest possible quality. Not sure what you’re in the mood for? Try Gotham Pizza’s Grandma Pizza, it’s the perfect bite to satisfy your hunger any time of day. Order online or stop by Gotham Pizza today!
First off, they gave me half my order of garlic knots. No big deal. When I called to ask about it, the guy nonchalantly said "yeah, we're about to close." When I asked him if he was going to refund me, he got very irritated and yelled "My friend! It's only a dollar! You pay on Seamless! I give you credit!" and hung up on me. Now I'm upset and there's nothing I can do about it.
Secondly, I paid $20 for a 12" pizza and 8 garlic knots (only 4 of which showed up). It showed up relatively soon but still somehow cold and dry. And that much for such a small amount of food, you'd think it would show up and be $20 worth of quality. I can get more and better from my local dollar pizza place for half the price.
Posted a year ago by Doran B.
Best pizza in the neighborhood. Always arrives hot and fresh.
Posted a year ago by Jessie U.
The pizza arrived within the window however the delivery guy called and was trying to make me come down from my apartment to the street to get my pizza. Now it is after midnight, he is calling and screaming at me to come outside ..... single girl here not going to be doing that. I left him a great tip here too on the app which kills me because I had to argue with him 3 separate times over the phone to make him come up. It's called delivery for a reason right? I thought the purpose was they came up to your door? Every other delivery guy has done that.... anyway I won't be ordering from here again.... the coked out death stare I received complimentary to my pizza was unpleasantly more than I wanted from Gotham Pizza.
Posted a year ago by Lindsay M.
Great pizza, crust was excellent.. Fast and fresh.
Posted a year ago by Miranda W.
Best White Pie in the UES!
Posted a year ago by Michael K.
The pizza is one of the better deliveries I have had. Unfortunately, the service is abominable. For my last 3 orders, the food was delivered more than 30 minutes outside of the range given. As well, with two of the orders, I did not receive the garlic knots I was charged for. The first time, they told me they would send it with the next order I place (which they did; but they only sent me one order of the knots, not the two I had paid for and not receive in the previous order). The second time they did not deliver the garlic knots, they thought it would suffice to give me a can of coca cola instead, again because they were "out". 1) How are you out of garlic knots? 2) Why don't you call me?
After all of this and the rude customer service once I had got them on the phone, I will never order from Gotham Pizza again.
Posted a year ago by Philip B.
My favorite pizza shop on the UES. Delicious and you can eat it without feeling like your face is covered in grease afterwards.
Posted a year ago by Steve G.
Margherita taste like a true Italian Pizza, expensive like any other good place in NY.
Posted a year ago by alessandro f.
After waiting an hour I called the restaurant to have someone yelling at me, when I explained that I couldn't understand what he was saying he yelled again and hung up. I called back and he yelled at me for calling 3 times, which was his fault for screaming random words that make no sense.
Posted a year ago by Eva S.
This pizza was good! A little overpriced but it was some of the best I've had so I'll most likely go back.
Posted a year ago by Julia B.
They are usually good, even though my most recent order came a little burnt. Still, the pizza was good. Their turnaround time is quite fast, so that's always a plus. Some people might not like the thinness of the pizza but the balance between cheese/sauce/crust is actually perfect. Definitely worth ordering but if you're hungry, get a little more than you might otherwise order.
Posted a year ago by Richard P.
Over the winter I've ordered from many pizza places looking for the best one I could find. Their pizza is absolutely the best one I could find in NYC. The dough is crunchy and not too thin not too thick and the ingredients are very fresh and tasty. Try the sausage regular 16 inch. It's fantastic. Fast delivery too.
Posted a year ago by Cosmin C.
Very good pizza, delivery can be slow
Posted a year ago by Michel S.
Easily the best pizza in E. Harlem. We've tried them all.
Posted a year ago by Chris W.
This is terrible pizza, it was over cocked and tasted bad. Never order from Here
Posted a year ago by Eileen K.
I have had, for the most part, very delicious pizza's from this place. Last night was an exception...but I have to say--it was pretty awful. When I order olives on my pizza I want just that. Last night my pizza barely had any cheese and was basically olives with a crust under it. What????? Three stars because they are generally very good. But when they are "off", they are WAY off....
Posted a year ago by abigail c.
Solid go-to. Sometimes comes extremely crisp, other times slightly soggy, but always flavorful and fast.
Posted a year ago by Graham T.
My favorite pizza place in the area, but unfortunately lately they've been delivering them cold to us. After this happening enough times, I'm forced to order from other places. Fix your delivery system and we'll be back!
Posted a year ago by Rose T.
D. Lish. Us.
Posted a year ago by Justin H.
Good food. Like the corn meal on the bottom of the pizza's, very good thin crust. Sometimes forget toppings, which are not cheap at $1.50 a piece. Also the garlic knots are a great deal, usually get more than four.
Posted a year ago by Alexandra L.
Excellent pizza. You can't go wrong with the Grandma or their regular pies.
Posted a year ago by Patrick K.
Delivery was pretty fast but the pizza was really cold. They also forgot the beverage I ordered and only offered me a credit for the next order which is not acceptable since I won't order cold Pizza again. They then said they'll figure out with the delivery guy but I'm still waiting for the call... very unfriendly!
Posted a year ago by Stefanie B.
I just ate here for the first time. I ordered a standard small, pepperoni and mushroom pie and was told it would take 60-75 mins to arrive. Surprisingly, my pie arrived in 25 minutes and the pie was hot and delicious! I will definitely be reordering!
Posted a year ago by juan w.
Just o-k. Certainly safe to order when there's not a better alternative! I would not consider this the epitome of a classic 'NYC pizza'. Texture is ok, sauce is ok, and toppings are ok, but nothing is particularly great. We've ordered from them three times now and while I don't have any particular complaints (beyond their tumble-off-a-slice chunk-style cutting of pepper toppings), I'm ready to move on to find a better pizza place. The orders have always arrived within reasonable time, if not sooner.
Posted a year ago by Hilary B.
My new favorite pizza delivery place in the hood. The square grandma's pizza was delish. One of the better pizza places I've tried on Seamless.
Posted a year ago by Nora N.
Great Grandma Slices and Garlic Knots and quick delivery. I used to order from Papa Johns but since not since I've discovered Gotham Pizza.
Posted a year ago by Amanda W.
I LOVE THE PIZZA! The regular pie is so good. Finally, I can order good pizza in Harlem. I asked for extra sauce and they gave me a whole cup full! I asked for lots of napkins and they sent that too! This is my new go to place for pizza delivery.
Posted a year ago by Tammy G.
Best pizza in the neighborhood by far! Wish they had additional items/sides on the menu besides pizza. But if pizza is what you want, this is the best.
Posted a year ago by Valerie F.
One of the best pizza delivery places in the area as far as delivery time, food quality and consistency goes. It's my go-to for a pepperoni pizza.
Posted a year ago by Kevin R.
Basic cheese pizza is good. However, this is the second time that I ordered garlic knots and they didn't have them. They didn't refund the money, said they can't do that and told me next time just to ask for a soda. I suspect that it is not even an item on their menu, which is ok, but remove it from the selection.
Posted a year ago by Susan B.
The pizza is good; however, twice they have taken over 90 minutes to deliver on a 30-45 minute order, with no notice or apology. I will not order from them again.
Posted a year ago by Richard S.
30-45 minute estimate. It's been 92 minutes and 2 phone calls. Where is my pizza?!!!!!!!!
Posted a year ago by jeremy f.
Extremely late (+75min). When I tried to call the restaurant to figured out why my delivery was late,the staff was really rude, almost insulting. Quite disappointing for what is both the first and the last time I order food at Gotham Pizza.
Posted a year ago by Sebastien N.
Took an hour and a half for delivery. When I called to see where it was, they said you'll have to wait and hung up. When it finally arrived it was cold.
Posted a year ago by Jeffrey W.
best pizza in yorkville
Posted a year ago by Kirsten T.
Probably the best pizza I've had in this neighborhood. Worth the price.
Posted a year ago by amanda B.
The pizza is delicious. The service is good and they have always accommodated special requests with the orders.
Posted 2 years ago by Ashley M.
The pizza arrived cold and old it was not fresh it took way too long for the delivery and I'm never going to order from Gotham again. I'm very disappointed in tonight's order.
Posted 2 years ago by Adrienne G.
Honestly, not as great as the other reviews make it seem. Delivery took an hour, but thats no mark against the food, the pizza is no where near top 50 in this city, its edible but nothing to write home about, and the garlic knots are your mediocre style not enough garlic, little too crunchy.
Posted 2 years ago by Natalie J.
Their Margherita pizza is wonderful! Delivery is always consistent. They are the best!
Posted 2 years ago by brittney r.
Some of the best pizza there is on the UES, crust can be a little hard some times, but overall it's my go to
Posted 2 years ago by Andrew M.
Best pizza on the UES! Thin, flaky crust and the perfect balance of sauce to cheese!
Posted 2 years ago by Elkin N.
excellent pizza - always fresh and good. speedy delivery. highly recommend.
Posted 2 years ago by melissa m.
Always get a square pizza and its awesome. Not too much dough, cooked just right and made fresh.
Posted 2 years ago by David P.
Had to call after 50 minutes to check on order. Turns out they ran out of something and offered to give me something else (not of equal value) - second time that has happened to me. When the pizza arrived, it was a plain slice with warmed up slices of pepperoni thrown on top. Disappointed. They were having a busy night, but should make up for making the customer wait - instead of rushing an order out the door.
Posted 2 years ago by Kay L.
Great Pizza and fast delivery.
Posted 2 years ago by Irene A.
Pizza took over an hour to arrive and was cold.
Posted 2 years ago by Christina M.
Fast delivery but slices were delivered layered on top of each other. Messy and not appetizing
Posted 2 years ago by Heather F.
Consistent fast delivery. Garlic knots are very garlicky- beware!!
Posted 2 years ago by LISA H.
Thin Crust Regular Cheese Pizza is our to-order dish. Service is quick and quality consistent.
Posted 2 years ago by Christina Shih-Yun C.
Amazing margherita pizza!!!
Posted 2 years ago by Leon P.
Most consistent good pizza on the UES and quick delivery. Very pleased they let us order by the slice as well.
Posted 2 years ago by Christopher J.
Garlic knots and margherita pizza were awesome
Posted 2 years ago by Prasanna V.
I've been waiting for an hour and the pizzas are still not here. Tired of waiting.
Posted 2 years ago by Joseph E.
Love, love, love the Margherita Pizza!! I wish more restaurants would focus on one thing and do it GREAT, rather than try to offer too many other options and have them all be mediocre.
Posted 2 years ago by Danielle O.
Love Grandma's Pizza
Posted 2 years ago by Kellie R.
The pizza was delivered after 1hr and 30 minutes late by the time I received it, it was too cold . Definitely not worth waiting for and had no NY pizza flavor.
Posted 2 years ago by Victor L.
I've been ordering this pizza for 2 years and have never had anything wrong with any order. It is my second favorite pizza place besides my #1 spot in BK. Their cheese pizza and white slices are amazing. Really very very good and i highly recommend it !!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Posted 2 years ago by lauren b.
The pizza is definitely better in the store as opposed to delivery.
Posted 2 years ago by Sara K.
I always order the Margherita pizza and when its good- its very very good (5 stars) but a few times its been overcooked and all greasy and gross (1 star) and the last time I ordered I ended up binning most of it. Delivery is consistently prompt.
Posted 2 years ago by Stephanie S.
I love the Margherita Pizza here so much that I somehow manage to finish an entire pie by myself. Once, I ordered a pizza and was called in to work while I was waiting. The pizza delivery guy had already left the store and I wouldn't be at home when he delivered. They had already charged my credit card. I called the next day and the manager (super nice guy) hooked me up with a new pie for free. I'll always recommend this place because the manager was real with me and empathized with my situation.
Posted 2 years ago by Jonathan M.
The margherita pizza is delicious!
Posted 2 years ago by Louis T.
I've given this place a second chance and it let me down again. I just don't think the pizza here is good. The dough is strange and the toppings/cheese are just bland. First time I had a slice I had to look for something to sprinkle on the pizza, preferably salt. Second time we ordered a whole small pizza and I didn't even want to eat more than one slice. Don't order sausage, it's too overpowering. But if you do get something, get the garlic knots, they're decent.
Posted 2 years ago by Anh P.
I don't understand some of these bad reviews. The pizza at Gotham is fabulous. I have never been delivered a cold pie, nor a greasy pie. The toppings are fresh and hot, and the crust is perfect every time. Everyone likes a different kind of crust, and for me, Gotham's is just right. Not too doughy, but not too crisp. What can I say without sounding like Goldilocks? Just try the pizza.
Posted 2 years ago by John D.
should not be a "$$" rating - $22 for a Grandma pie? it's 6 slices total. the pizza is good but way over priced
Posted 2 years ago by Michelle E.
Paid for a full pepperoni pizza but asked for half pepperoni / half plain in the special instruction b/c my girlfriend can't eat pork... Received a full pepperoni... Thanks for following simple instructions! Did not receive the side of Parmesan cheese I asked for either... There's no excuse! The special instructions are in BOLD print! Thanks again! I'm super satisfied!
Posted 2 years ago by Selma D.
Pizza was soggy and flavorless. I definitely won't order from here again!
Posted 2 years ago by Sarah B.
Very quick delivery, but only OK pizza. I am a little surprised how well rated this place is.
Posted 2 years ago by William T.
This pizza was not good. The crust was thin and textured and flaky in a bad way. It was greasy and all around disappointing. If you're going to splurge and eat pizza, definitely don't get this.
Posted 2 years ago by Daniel G.
I must say. I bought the Grandma's pizza on a whim and it is awesome. Huge pizza, they always deliver really fast the last 3 times I ordered and the pizza is really good. Feeds like 4 people, easy.
Posted 2 years ago by Ross M.
Good pizza and delivery guys. Yes it may be overpriced, but so is everything on the UES, and I'm happy to have a reliably good pizza delivery so I'll deal with the price. More topping variety would be nice though!
Posted 3 years ago by Jessica R.
This was the first place I ordered delivery from since moving to UES, and I was like hm pretty good. I kept trying other places because I thought I might be missing a really good pizza place with a low rating. Guess what. This IS THE BEST pizza place. ever. Man. to think of all the money I've wasted trying different places... I am never going to doubt this place again. Gotham Pizza rocks! :)
Posted 3 years ago by Rylee K.
The pizza is nothing special. It's just average. There's got to be better pizza on the Upper East Side.
Posted 3 years ago by Ben O.
Delivery guys are always nice and pizza is always good, but it's always cold.
Posted 3 years ago by adrienne b.
great for a nice slice of peperoni! arrived fast and piping hot! will order again!
Posted 3 years ago by Hercy H.
Not sure why this Pizza is rated so high. I've had the regular pizza and sicilian. Both pies are not only small in size, but thin, and just ridiculously overpriced. There are better options in the area, take it from a real pizza lover and skip this waste of a meal.
Posted 3 years ago by Bill S.
Too expensive for a pizza.
Posted 3 years ago by Michelle C.
grandma square was legitamate
Posted 3 years ago by Vivek J.
The pizza tasted fine, delivery was quick, but for the cost I was bummed at the size / amount of toppings. Probably going to stick with other places instead of trying a new place.
Posted 3 years ago by Mark F.
Awesome, I think. FIrst time ordering.
Posted 3 years ago by Greg G.
Very good pizza and reasonable delivery times.
Posted 3 years ago by Nick B.
Very clean, simple, good tasting pizza. would definitely order from here again. Delivery time was also pretty decent.
Posted 3 years ago by tina j.
Terrible service. We placed an order at 7:17pm. At 8:30pm, we called the restaurant to find out why our order was late. They told us it would be delivered in 10 minutes and that the delivery guy had already left. After 30 minutes the pizza still hadn't been delivered. We called back and the story changed. Apparently, the delivery guy had an accident and lost our ticket. They informed us it would only take 10 mins and that the delivery guy had already left. 20 minutes later, the pizza still had not been delivered. We called and canceled the order, but the guy I spoke to insisted that the delivery guy had already left. It's 10:21pm and no pizza had been delivered. Never order from this place. Horrible service.
Posted 3 years ago by Brian S.
great pizza, nice crust, delivery took a while
Posted 3 years ago by dodai s.
2 HOURS AND 28 MINUTES. Don't order from here if you expect to eat when you're hungry. It will probably get there at the same time as the ambulance. The one picking you up for starvation.
Posted 3 years ago by Thomas B.
So delicious! Update: quality has gone down a bit, but still tasty. Fast delivery, warm pizza.
Posted 3 years ago by Daniel P.
First time I ordered from Gotham I got the Grandma's Square Pizza. I haven't ordered anything else since, it's unreal.
Posted 3 years ago by Michael T.
The BEST pizza in NYC
Posted 4 years ago by Jessica V.
great delivery pizza
Posted 4 years ago by Efrain R.
Grandmas pizza with sausage and mushroom was delicious!
Posted 4 years ago by Andrew C.
Ordered a Grandma Square Pizza w/ meatballs. Delivery was fast and pleasant. It was a decent pizza, filling albeit extremely rich. That said, it wasn't meatballs on top, rather slices of some mystery meat sausage. Would not order again if there was alternatives.
Posted 4 years ago by Jacob Langvad N.
nice crust, good sauce, fresh toppings...the sausage and mushroom are expecially yummy...
Posted 4 years ago by christine p.
The only good thing to be said for this place is that the delivery was prompt. The pizza was cold, oily, flavorless, with a crust was dry and soggy at the same time. The caeser salad consisted of lackluster romaine leaves dusted with powdered fake parmesan and served with Ken's salad dressing. 'nuff said.
Posted 4 years ago by Rachel B.
flavors were great, but by the time i received the pizza almost all of the sauce and cheese was congealed to the top of the box. i basically paid a lot of money to eat soggy pizza crust and cheese with pieces of cardboard stuck to it. i don't understand why they don't use the little plastic thing in the center of the box like every other place does. or how about not smashing the cardboard top into the pizza!
Posted 4 years ago by susan c.
Food is decent for the price. Always fast delivery. Overall, I would recommend.
Posted 4 years ago by Lynn B.
Great crispy crust pizza. Very unique method using breadcrumbs instead of cornmeal to get that extra crunch. A neighborhood gem.
Posted 4 years ago by Vanessa R.
Gotham's pizza is a great spin on New York pizza. They give the crust a little bit more of a fried texture that you might expect from a deep dish style pizza, but the taste is still New York authentic.
Posted 4 years ago by Richard G.
Crispier take on the classic NY slice (not for the paper-thin blister crust lover though). Consistently quick and friendly service.
Posted 4 years ago by Michelle M.
Pretty good -- not what I would consider to be the quintessential "authentic" NYC pizza, but good in its own way. Very interesting (and tasty) crust!
Posted 4 years ago by Bragg V.
Great pizza, fast delivery. (oh and extra garlicy garlic knots!)
Posted 4 years ago by Erin B.
The White Pizza at Gotham is super delicious -- I recommend adding on sausage and/or spinach. While the pizza isn't anything out of the ordinary, it will certainly fulfill your craving for sauceless pizza -- and the next you know, you've ate the whole! But if not, it's great cold and reheated!
Posted 4 years ago by Jennifer F.
NEVER ORDER FROM THIS PLACE. THEY ARE DISHONEST. I have ordered several times and last night put in an order for the kids and babysitter before leaving the house. The pizza was never delivered and they claim that they rang the bell but nobody answered. When I asked why they didn't call, they said they were calling and left several messages. I received no messages. They then told me they did not know which apartment I was in and I told them that if they'd actually come here, they would have noticed it was a single residence. At that point they said that the guy never actually came. Now I have to get a credit through Seamlessweb because they are not offering to help.
Posted 4 years ago by Laura O.
The pizza with everything on it was sooo good!!!
Posted 4 years ago by Rick d.
it took double the time they promised, and the delivery guy wouldn't give me my food unless i tipped extra on top of the tip i already gave.
Posted 4 years ago by Cliff K.
Loved the pizza from this place.
Posted 4 years ago by Shoji S.
Try the house special..$15 dollars for a 12' with everything on it....YUM!
Posted 4 years ago by Denes K.
Pizza was delicious! Caesar salad was a generous portion! Good...all around. Friendly delivery.
Posted 4 years ago by Dee K.
this is just a standard good pizza. if you want pizza, this is a safe bet and you will be satisified.
Posted 4 years ago by Michael L.
this gotham is excellent. finally great pizza in this neighborhood.
Posted 4 years ago by Bernard G.
Great pizza, great salads, and impeccable service - I never review places, but this one deserves a note because the service guys are always prompt and super friendly. Just now, I had a salad delivered without dressing, and before realizing that the dressing was missing, the delivery guy had returned with dressing without being asked, with no additional charge and with a smile on his face.
Posted 5 years ago by Nick M.
Best delivery pizza I've had on the UES. Pie could be a little thinner but otherwise very nice.
Posted 5 years ago by Natasha H.
It is the best Pizza I have ever had!!! The pizzas are baked to perfection and the peporoni is the best! I LOVE IT!!
Posted 5 years ago by Dawn t.
Best pizza on the UES
Posted 5 years ago by Tim M.
The grandma pizza is delicious! I order this pie all the time and the ingredients are always fresh, the toppings are well balanced and my order is always correct and delivered within the quoted time.
Posted 5 years ago by Allison A.
Worst pizza pie we've ever eaten. Completely tasteless and arrived with half of the pizza slid under the other half, all the contents slipped off into the box. We ended up throwing it away after eating one piece each. Avoid this place.
Posted 5 years ago by Richard Z.
Surprisingly good pizza and very friendly staff
Posted 5 years ago by Helen W.
Great pizza and fast delivery!
Posted 5 years ago by Laura C.
great thin crust pizza
Posted 5 years ago by Shalini B.
Best Sicilian pizza I've had in New York, great thin crust (and the meatball topping is surprisingly good!)
Posted 5 years ago by Christine N.
Grandma's pizza w/sausage and pepperoni... OMG AMAZING!
Posted 5 years ago by gary k.
I used to pass by Gotham Pizza late at night when I lived in the East 70's wishing it was open for a slice to try. Now, newly opened in the East 80's where I currently live, I was finally able to check it out.
Ordered a small pie with a sampling of toppings to get a real taste for the place. And WOW was it good, so refreshing from other places in the area and really really fresh.
I will definitely be stopping by more often (and ordering online)
Posted 5 years ago by Elliott W.
The pizza is generally very delicious & I order from here frequently, but the crust is a bit too stiff, in my opinion.
Posted 5 years ago by Tim H.
Only select user reviews are published on Seamless. All user-submitted ratings contribute to Gotham Pizza (1st Ave)'s overall Seamless rating, but we manually screen all reviews and only publish those that are relevant and helpful. Tips for getting your review published »
Above content provided by restaurant.
Order online from
Gotham Pizza (1st Ave) by entering your address
below. Online ordering powered by Seamless.com.
Return users log
Click a menu item to add it to your order.
Back to top
Seamless North America, LLC. All Rights Reserved.
0808 234 7862
Seamless North America, LLC. All Rights Reserved.